The Attention Span of an Ant
I put a paper wall in front of an ant. It turns right. I put up the paper wall again. The ant turns right again. I put up the paper wall and the ant takes a left. We all have it in us, this reflex response to a stimulus. We all have the insect/reptilian part of our brains that does not think, but just reacts. Interestingly, the personal publishing revolution and all the new content streams that have been built up around us have the effect of turning would be writers and intellectuals, the creative class, into a colony of insects impulsively repeating this message or that message. Why have we turned ourselves into repeater stations susceptible to any clever or not so clever marketing trick? Why have we substituted careful reasoning, research, and analysis for sound bites and regurgitated news?
This insect like response to the latest trends and the buzz of the moment was the domain of newspaper reporters and the press core. More sensible people went into different professions that gave them time to think and learn and develop their specialty. However, we bloggers have recently taken it upon ourselves to usurp “old media,” and takeover their responsibilities. Why? Because, we believe that citizen journalists can do it better?
Maybe this is true, but my general inclination is to step back and say, “wait a minute.” I don’t want this responsibility. That’s why I didn’t become a reporter! I want to think things out and learn how they actually work. I want to understand PR and marketing as it relates to human behavior.
I don’t want to hear a million microsecond pitches about what’s hot and what’s not. Trends today are as long lived as a mayfly, and therefore utterly useless to anyone who wants to understand the overall picture of what is going on in the marketplace of ideas. Ideas are the only things that really matter, and all that jabber out there is only relevant to the extent that it reinforces one idea over another. So, my suggestion to bloggers is stop reading your news feeds and THINK!
I know that there are a lot of PR and marketing people that would love to see the blogosphere continue in the direction that it is heading. The marketing industry would absolutely love it, if we just responded to the most talked about thing on the Internet, and posted it to our blogs. And, they would love it even more, if we felt compelled to do this two, three, four times per day. The more time we spend posting regurgitated news, and the less time we spend thinking, the better it is for them.
We become the mouth piece of whatever is hot on Google, Technorati, Delicious, etc.. There are a thousand tricks to get to the top of these information aggregation engines and marketing professionals are increasingly using every trick in the book to get highly ranked. The more time we spend thinking and the less time we spend posting the harder it is for marketers to get the questionable ideas and products out there. As thinkers, we become better gatekeepers and the line between news and advertising naturally begins to reemerge.
There are many of forces pushing bloggers in the reactive unthinking direction. For instance, bloggers need to maintain a steady stream of content to maintain readership, and blogging communities tend towards a cliquish culture that naturally repeats what other bloggers in that community are saying. However, there is definitely a push in the blogsphere to find ways of differentiating quality content that is worth reading from advertorials and other bilious crap.
To mindlessly repeat some things I’ve heard: Craig Newmark and Jeff Jarvis are making rumbling about a new service that will help determine the best news out there; Corante has added “hubs” of edited content from bloggers writing on specialized topic areas; and there are countless other projects in the works. Please let me know about any services you’ve heard of that help filter and improve the quality of information in the blogosphere. I’ll be blogging on this topic a lot in the near future.
The staff of American Madness would like to thank the 